The Right to Be Real: The Verdict Is In - UK Supreme Court Says Women Are Born, Not Made
In the name of inclusion, we risk disappearing the very people rights were meant to protect. If rights are real, then reality must matter too.
By Gem Musings
In every democracy, there comes a time when courts must step in—not to redefine truth but to remind society that facts still exist.
That moment arrived in the UK when the Supreme Court delivered what can only be described as a masterclass in legal clarity: sex, under the Equality Act 2010, means biological sex. Man or woman. Not vibes. Not intention. Not identity as performance. Just plain biology.
The ruling has been hailed as a win for women—but it’s more than that. It’s a check on ideological overreach, a rebuke to the creeping notion that belief must be enforced, not earned. For years, women’s rights campaigners like For Women Scotland were told they were bigots, dinosaurs, or worse—for daring to say what every biology textbook still teaches: you can change your name, your style, even your paperwork—but not your chromosomes.
Of course, this isn’t about chromosomes. It’s about power, and who gets to define reality. In recent years, the trans rights movement—at least in its loudest, most militant form—has done something dangerously clever: it recast disagreement as hatred. It turned honest questions into moral crimes.
“Trans women are women” became a litmus test for decency, and anyone who flinched, even politely, was labelled transphobic and tossed into the bonfire of cancel culture.
This UK ruling pushes back against that dynamic. It says, in effect: We see you. We respect your journey. But the law cannot be based on make-believe. You do not get to erase the material category of “woman” just because you feel like one.
"I love it when a plan comes together": Author JK Rowling celebrates the ruling with a drink and a cigar.
She has long been a target of transgender activists who accuse her of being hateful due to her assertion that only women are women.
Rowling reportedly donated £70,000 (about Kshs 12 million) to For Women Scotland, the campaign group that argued the case.
Why does this matter beyond Britain? Because all over the world—from Nairobi to New York—gender identity politics have collided with women’s hard-won rights, and the results aren’t pretty. In sport, in shelters, in prisons, and in public appointments, women born women are being pushed aside, told to “be kind,” and made to compete not just with men, but with men who now identify as women and insist on full access to the very spaces meant to shield women from male advantage.
Let’s be honest: this isn’t always about equality. Sometimes, it’s about opportunism. In parts of the world, we’d call it ukora—a cheeky term for trickery dressed up as strategy. A man declares himself a woman and suddenly qualifies for a seat, a scholarship, a slot, or a medal. You didn’t suffer the marginalization, but you want the spoils. And when women protest, you accuse them of bigotry.
This is not justice. This is identity laundering, and it’s bad ethics in progressive clothing.
The irony? Many of the people being silenced today were once at the forefront of fighting injustice. Now, they’re told to sit down and shut up—because their biology offends someone's belief system.
If that sounds familiar, it’s because power always rebrands itself.
Foucault taught us that power doesn’t just repress; it produces knowledge, categories, language. And right now, a new orthodoxy is being produced—where rights are not grounded in reality, but in how loudly you demand to be believed.
But real inclusion doesn’t erase. Real equality doesn’t cancel. And real rights don’t require you to pretend.
You can live as you wish. You can dress, transition, and identify as your soul requires. But you cannot demand that others surrender their understanding of reality to validate your own. That’s not inclusion—it’s epistemic domination.
And the more we let identity trump truth, the more we hollow out the very foundations of rights-based justice.
In other words: if you want to be seen, don’t erase others.
Gem Musings is a seasoned International Relations and Public Affairs Strategist with extensive experience in global diplomacy, communication, and policy analysis.